takingpitches
  • Economy
  • Enterprise
  • Marketplaces
  • Random
  • Life
  • Talent
  • Trading
  • Travel
Trending
Recycled Wind Turbines could be transformed into Plexiglass,...
The risk of suicide among children increases during...
It’s a great idea. Artificial Intelligence Learns like...
Dogs do tear up when Their Owners Return...
30 One-Sentence Stories From People Who Have Built...
7 Ways to Retain More of Every Book...
The following are seven ways that living in...
Five Mindsets that Create Success
They will give the game away FIFA 22...
Since February, the rouble has closed at its...
takingpitches
  • Economy
  • Enterprise
  • Marketplaces
  • Random
  • Life
  • Talent
  • Trading
  • Travel
Category:

Creating Business Plans

    Creating Business Plans

    Elon Musk: The Role of Analogy and Reasoning From First Principles in Disruptive Entrepreneurship

    by takingpitches September 22, 2012
    written by takingpitches

    In terms of getting an insight into “Tony Stark’s” head, the last 5-ish minutes of Kevin’s Rose’s Foundation interview of Elon Musk is a gem:

    I think its important to reason from first principles rather than by analogy…The normal way we conduct our lives is we reason by analogy…

    We are doing this because it’s like something else that was done..or it is like what other people are doing…slight iterations on a theme…

    “First principles” is a physics way of looking at the world…what that really means is that you boil things down to the most fundamental truths…and then reason up from there…that takes a lot more mental energy…

    Someone could –and people do — say battery packs are really expensive and that’s just the way they will always be because that’s the way they have been in the past…

    They would say it’s going to cost, historically it cost $600 KW/hour.  It’s not going to be much better that in the future…

    So first principles..we say what are the material constituents of the batteries.  What is the spot market value of the material constituents?  It has carbon, nickel, aluminum, and some polymers for separation, and a steel can..break that down on a material basis, if we bought that on a London Metal Exchange, what would each of these things cost.  oh geez…It’s $80 KW/hour.  Clearly, you need to think of clever ways to take those materials and combine them into the shape of a battery cell, and you can have batteries that are much cheaper than anyone realizes.

    The contrast that Elon makes is between reasoning by analogy and reasoning from first principles, i.e., finding fundamental principles and reasoning up from there. The assertion he makes is that the method of being truly creative is reasoning from first principles.

    This assertion is surprising in a sense.  We tend to intuitively think that reasoning by analogy is superior.  In fact, it is important in some cases, such as when you use an analogy that is distinct — bringing ideas from completely disparate fields to spark a new way of thinking of your problem.  Think of Da Vinci and Darwin.

    I think it’s better to think of Musk as criticizing close analogy.  This is dangerous in at least two ways.

    First, you can become an incremental thinker, chasing and seduced by ideas like:

    • We are the pinterest of X…
    • We are the foursquare of Y…

    This type of thinking is seductive in Tech World, in parts, because it is also very amenable to venture pitches, easy communication, and Tweets.

    Second, and I think perhaps more dangerous from Elon’s perspective is that analogical thinking squashes creative ideas.  The example he uses above — the cost of batteries — is illustrative.  Using reasoning by analogy, conventional wisdom drawn from past electric battery efforts was that cost could not be reduced past a certain point.

    As explained by Musk, from a first principle perspective, this was not true if you thought of the battery problem in terms of the cost of the components.

    Another example from Elon’s world is with rockets.  Analogizing to the experience and costs of government space programs hampered almost everyone’s thinking as to the viability of private space ventures.  SpaceX’s efforts, so far, have shattered this conventional wisdom, and manned space exploration is next on its radar.

    A place where this comes up in personal efforts at entrepreneurship is thinking about the way certain markets are today.  You have a choice:

    If you see a problem in the relation of a market structure and the results that flow from that structure, you can analogize to past or current status quo thinking, and can be deterred in moving forward, thinking that there is a good reason that past efforts have failed or there is an inevitable reason that the market structure is the way it is.

    Or, you can examine rigorously from a first principles perspective.  If after exhaustive exploration of the first principles, and the reasoning built on that, you can remain convinced that you are correct about the problem in market structure.  Then the question is do you have the courage to move forward and tackle it to change it and create customer value.

    September 22, 2012 0 comment
    0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • Creating Business Plans

    Domain Name Game

    by takingpitches April 29, 2011
    by takingpitches April 29, 2011

    Practical advice on buying a domain name from AVC.  This is the most useful insight for me: “A good domain name is…

    0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • Creating Business Plans

    Working Backwards at Amazon

    by takingpitches April 14, 2011
    by takingpitches April 14, 2011

    A nice post on Quora by Ian McAllister of Amazon on how to think of product management, starting with the press release…

    0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • Creating Business Plans

    Randy Komisar: Bigger the Problem, Better the Opportunity

    by takingpitches March 27, 2011
    by takingpitches March 27, 2011

    In working through a current business plan, I have been looking for some inspiration to organize my thoughts into a high-impact…

    0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
  • Creating Business Plans

    Khosla and “black swan” investing and entrepreneurship

    by takingpitches March 21, 2011
    by takingpitches March 21, 2011

    Some lessons about investing and entrepreneurship generally from an Economist article on Vinod Khosla where he discusses his philosophy regarding investing (clean-tech for him…

    0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest Snapchat

Popular Posts

  • 1

    Most Dangerous Sea Creatures

    September 7, 2020
  • 2

    30 One-Sentence Stories From People Who Have Built Better Habits

    May 20, 2022
  • 3

    7 Ways to Retain More of Every Book You Read

    May 20, 2022

Tweets

Missing consumer key - please check your settings in admin > Settings > Twitter Feed Auth

Categories

  • Apps (5)
  • Big Data (1)
  • Business (3)
  • Content Models (8)
  • Creating Business Plans (5)
  • Economy (15)
  • Enterprise (6)
  • Entertainment (1)
  • Health (4)
  • Internet Business Models (5)
  • Law, Policy, and Regulation 2.0 (3)
  • Life (21)
  • Local/Mobile (2)
  • Marketplaces (11)
  • Memories (1)
  • New Payment Systems (1)
  • News (1)
  • Post-Google Search (8)
  • Random (54)
  • Retail (and Selling Things) (4)
  • Science (3)
  • Social: Facebook/Twitter/Other (9)
  • Sports (1)
  • Sports (1)
  • Talent (17)
  • Thinking about Risk (3)
  • This Website (2)
  • Trading (5)
  • Travel (6)
  • TV Showbiz (2)
  • Uncategorized (5)
  • WHEATHER (1)

Recent Posts

  • Recycled Wind Turbines could be transformed into Plexiglass, Diapers , or Gummy Bears

    August 26, 2022
  • The risk of suicide among children increases during school Days

    August 26, 2022
  • It’s a great idea. Artificial Intelligence Learns like a Widdle Baby

    August 26, 2022
Footer Logo
  • Contact us
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Policy
  • Staff

@2022 - All Right Reserved


Back To Top